Craigslist Vehicle History Report VinInsights Scam

scamI purchased a new vehicle this week, and the old one went up for sale on Craigslist. I’m used to Internet scams but this one was pretty good.

Here’s how it went down.

Vehicle History Report Scam

The “buyer” began a conversation and asked if the vehicle was available and about maintenance records. After I answered, they came up with another dumb question. Finally, on the third email, after I offered up a CarFax report, they asked me to visit

Red flag.

Sine I work in Internet marketing I quickly noticed that redirects users to a website with a unique identifier and then shoots me over to

I’m not sure if is the scam or not or if the “marketer” is trying to make an affiliate commission on the $25 purchase.

Credit Card Theft?

After searching the web, I noticed this article from the BBB. Apparently, these fake sites are popping up in 2018. You go to the site, order your VIN report, and the thieves have your credit card information.

Trolling the Scammer

I kind of enjoy messing with scammers, so I went ahead and told “Michael Jones” that I purchased the report, but, I sold my vehicle before I could send him the report.

The scammer is going to be wondering why they didn’t get their referral fee or what is wrong once they hear that I completed the purchase successfully and they made $0 on it. hehe

Legitimate Title Reports

VehicleHistory.GOV lists legitimate title history reporting websites on their site. Surprisingly, CarFax is not one of them, however, many title searches begin at 6 bucks.

Did you fall for this scam?

Don’t worry! It happens to all of us and this one was pretty good. A lot of people only sell a car once in a great while. If you were scammed please let others know what happened in the comments section below.

I searched for sites using the identical text as VinInsights and found other sites which could be a scam as well (not sure) including and


President at Telapost
I create content and do SEO for law firms, small businesses and companies worldwide. I have been generating traffic online since 1992. I have owned multiple successful companies. I'm an organic eater, nature lover and German Shepherd owner. Feel free to contact me here.
  1. FWIW, the safecart link I was being sent was

  2. Glad I looked this up. Working in IT I am usually hard to fake out. But this one was just about to get me, I almost fell for it but then the tech in me said do a bit more digging before you put in your CC info. I have sold many cars in my past but they used to be so simple. No one wants to look anymore. I got this message after several email back and forth about my car and thought that is strange:

    “Sorry for late response, I would like to see a history report for your Cherokee. If you don’t own it, I would like to suggest if you can obtain it from They’re the most detailed report at this time and definitely way cheaper. I don’t want to get one on my own because it will become useless for me if we don’t make a deal. You could always use it as great sales tool to another interestedbuyer if our deal falls through. If everything is clean with the report, I would like to proceed with the deal and you can add cost of report to the vehicle price.”

    So the ling to takes me to and there starts the process. But again after selling cars a few times I remembered one thing. I shouldn’t have to pay to sell my car. If they want it they will pay for it and look it up. The buyer could have easily asked for the VIN to look it up himself if he was serious.

    Thanks for the post, I am glad I wasn’t caught.

    • Thanks Mike! Glad it helped someone. That is sound advice!! “I shouldn’t have to pay to sell my car”… Yeah they were pretty smooth…

  3. I am glad I looked up this service. Sounds like a scam to me. I have sold several vehicles on my own and never had a seller ask for a report. One had run their own report. This buyer said, “If everything is clean with the report, I would like to proceed with the deal and you can add cost of report to the vehicle price.” So I asked if I could use a service that was cheaper so that if he did not buy it then I would not be out as much money. He insisted I used VINInsights. So now I really don’t feel comfortable so I asked if I could use CarFax since I have used them and only add the $25 (VININsights fee) to the purchase price and I would eat the rest. Waiting to hear back from him. Bet he doesn’t answer or still insists on VINInsights. Thanks for sharing your experience.

Leave a Reply

SEO, Content Marketing, and Social Media Strategy varies drastically depending on which vertical you are in, where you are located, and more. CONTACT ME 919.475.1883